G7 vs G9 Laminate: Silicone-Glass vs Melamine-Glass

G7 and G9 are both glass-reinforced thermoset laminates used in demanding electrical and structural applications, but they are built on different resin systems and optimized for different failure modes. G7 uses a silicone resin binder, giving it the highest continuous service temperature of any standard glass-fabric laminate at 485°F (250°C) and excellent flame resistance. G9 uses a melamine-formaldehyde resin, which produces the best arc and track resistance of any grade in the NEMA/MIL laminate family — a critical property in switchgear and high-voltage bus assemblies. Choosing between them comes down to whether your assembly sees sustained heat or sustained arc exposure.

TL;DR

• G7 is rated for 485°F (250°C) continuous use; G9 is rated for 350°F (175°C).
• G9 has superior arc resistance and tracking resistance — the defining advantage in switchgear applications.
• Both comply with MIL-I-24768; G7 is type /17 (GS), G9 is type /2 (GMG).
• G7 maintains mechanical properties at temperatures that would degrade G9's resin system.
• G9 costs less than G7; silicone resins carry a price premium over melamine resins.
• G7 is the right call for furnace fixtures, aerospace thermal shields, and high-temperature motor components.
• G9 is the right call for bus bars, arc chutes, switchgear barriers, and any application requiring UL94 V-0 with arc resistance.

Side-by-Side Specifications

When to Choose G7 (Silicone-Glass)

Sustained High-Temperature Environments

G7 is the grade to specify when your assembly must operate continuously above 350°F. Silicone resin retains useful flexural modulus out to 485°F — temperatures that degrade melamine and most epoxy-glass laminates. Motor slot liners, oven conveyor fixtures, and aerospace thermal shield brackets all fall into this window.

Cryogenic and Wide Thermal Cycling Applications

Silicone's inherent elastomeric character gives G7 unusually good resistance to thermal cycling shock. Parts that see repeated excursions from sub-zero to high-heat (think aerospace or industrial test chambers) hold up better in G7 than in any of the more rigid thermoset grades.

Flame-Resistant Structural Members at Elevated Temperature

When a part needs to carry structural load and survive fire exposure simultaneously — transformer core clamps in utility equipment, for example — G7's combination of flame resistance and high-temperature stability is difficult to match with any other laminate.

Military and Aerospace MIL-I-24768/17 Callouts

Government drawings that call for MIL-I-24768/17 by name require G7. Substitution must be documented and approved; don't assume G10 or G11 covers the spec because they use epoxy resin systems with lower service temperatures.

When to Choose G9 (Melamine-Glass)

Switchgear, Bus Bars, and Arc Chutes

G9 is the industry standard for electrical switchgear barriers, arc chutes, and bus bar supports. Its melamine resin system chars and forms a carbonized layer that interrupts electrical tracking — a property arc-tracking resistant (ATR) grades are specifically engineered to deliver. When a fault current ignites an arc, a G9 barrier resists the spread of carbonized paths that would allow a second fault to follow.

High-Voltage Assemblies Requiring CTI Class I

Comparative Tracking Index (CTI) measures how readily a material surface develops a conductive carbon track under voltage stress with contaminant. G9 routinely scores 600 V CTI (Class I per IEC 60112), the highest class. Specify G9 when your creepage-and-clearance design depends on Class I surface insulation.

Medium-Temperature Electrical Enclosures and Panels

For electrical switchboard panels, insulating standoffs, and relay board substrates that operate at normal industrial temperatures (ambient to 300°F), G9 is the cost-effective choice. You get excellent electrical properties without paying for silicone resin's high-temperature capability that you won't use.

Arc-Resistant Terminal Blocks and Connector Housings

In applications where repeated arcing is expected — open-frame relays, high-current connectors, overcurrent protection assemblies — G9's arc resistance of ~180 seconds (vs ~120 for G7) is the deciding factor.

Specs Head-to-Head

Thermal Performance

The temperature gap between G7 and G9 is significant. G7's silicone resin retains a flexural strength above 20,000 psi at 400°F; G9's melamine resin begins to show measurable strength loss above 300°F. For furnace-adjacent parts or any assembly in a Class H or Class N motor insulation system, G7 is the only glass-fabric laminate that meets the thermal requirement without moving to more exotic materials like polyimide film laminates.

G9's 350°F continuous rating is more than adequate for most switchgear applications, where the thermal load comes from resistive heating of current-carrying conductors rather than from an external heat source. A 1,000 A bus bar may see surface temperatures of 200–250°F under load — well within G9's capability.

Electrical Properties

Both grades have similar bulk dielectric strength, typically 350–400 V/mil through the laminate thickness. The critical difference is surface behavior. Melamine resin carbonizes under arc stress rather than forming a continuous conductive track; silicone resin is also arc-resistant but produces a silica-based residue that can itself be somewhat conductive over time. For arc chute and bus support applications, G9's superior CTI is a genuine engineering advantage, not just a data-sheet number.

G7 has lower water absorption (0.1–0.2% vs 0.5–1.0% for G9), which gives it more stable dielectric properties in humid environments over long service life. If your insulator is outdoors or in a condensing environment and arc resistance is not the primary concern, G7's moisture stability is an advantage.

Mechanical Strength

G9 has a slight edge in flatwise tensile and flexural strength at room temperature, reflecting that melamine crosslinks more densely than silicone at ambient conditions. At elevated temperature, the relationship reverses: G7 retains strength to 485°F while G9 softens progressively above 350°F. For purely structural, room-temperature applications, G9 is the stronger and cheaper choice.

Chemical Resistance

Both grades are resistant to most common industrial solvents and hydrocarbon oils. G9 is somewhat more susceptible to hydrolysis in prolonged wet environments because melamine is slightly more moisture-sensitive than silicone. G7 handles steam environments better. Neither grade is suitable for strong acids or alkalis without protective coatings.

Cost and Availability

G7 sheet, rod, and tube are stocked by specialty laminate distributors but in smaller inventories than the more common G10 and FR4 grades. Silicone resin carries a significant cost premium — expect G7 to run 1.5–2.5× the price of equivalent G10 and roughly 20–40% more than G9.

G9 is more widely stocked in sheet form for switchgear fabrication. Standard sheet sizes (36″ × 48″, 48″ × 96″) are available in thicknesses from 0.062″ to 2.0″ from multiple distributors. Rod and tube are available but require planning — lead times of 2–6 weeks from specialty suppliers are common for non-sheet forms.

Both grades are available in natural (off-white to tan) color. Machined tolerances of ±0.005″ on milled features and ±0.003″ on ground surfaces are achievable in both materials with carbide tooling.

Common Alternatives

If neither G7 nor G9 fits your application, consider:

• G10 and FR4 — the most widely stocked and lowest-cost glass-epoxy laminate; rated to ~266°F (130°C) continuous. See the G10 vs G11 comparison for high-temperature epoxy-glass options.
• G11 — high-temperature epoxy-glass, rated to ~300°F (150°C); better than G10 in heat but below G9 in arc resistance.
• Polyimide-glass (NEMA GI) — for continuous service above 500°F where G7 is marginal; very expensive, limited availability.
• Phenolic-paper (XXXP/XXXPC) — lower cost, lower performance; suitable only for dry, lower-voltage applications. See the phenolic-paper vs phenolic-glass comparison.

Related Guides

More related guides

Explore related material decisions and where these plastics show up in real production:

Applications

• Electrical Insulation
• Aerospace Interior

Industries

• Aerospace
• Electrical Power

Other comparisons

• FR4 Vs. G7
• FR4 Vs. G9
• G7 Phenolic hub
• G9 Phenolic hub